Three Steps to Keep Health and Benefits Plan Costs Under Control
The ongoing coronavirus pandemic has highlighted how critical employee health is for business success. But mounting costs mean organizations must balance cost control with managing people risks. Here we set out three steps to make sure you’re protecting your most valuable asset without breaking your budget.
There’s no questioning that the cost of health and benefits plans is increasing rapidly. And while the pandemic meant a slight dip to the level of cost escalation, our research shows that, on average, medical costs outpace general inflation by close to three times.
The pandemic may mean an even sharper rise in costs as the cancellation of many elective procedures and a dip in preventive and emergency treatment lead to worsening health conditions in the immediate and long term.
Unsurprisingly, businesses are urgently seeking ways to economize and improve efficiencies in their health-related plans. Employers must take quick action to modernize, optimizing value to ensure programs are both cost-effective and encourage and improve employee health.
Achieving this means addressing three key areas:
1. Dealing with poor plan design (design for value)
Misdiagnoses, complications, and hospital-borne infections are just some of the consequences of poor initial care that add unnecessary cost and degrade the patient experience and outcomes. Not only is the employer paying for medical wastage, disability, and absence, but employees are left worse off, with some experiencing a decrease in quality or even length of life.
Plan design is crucial for containing costs by guiding employees toward quality, cost-effective providers. This is not about providing employees with suboptimal healthcare. If medical spend is not laser-focused on quality solutions everyone loses out.
- Cost sharing techniques like deductibles, co-payments, and coinsurance (ideally tiered in a way that encourages best practice, cost-effective care).
- Defined contribution approaches that share costs with employees while broadening choice.
- The role of individual plans through voluntary insurance.
- Pre-authorization for specialist visits or reapproval (e.g., physiotherapy treatments after six visits).
- Paying providers for treatment packages instead of a la carte to ensure they have the incentive to manage complications.
- Evaluating insurers based on claims management and provider network monitoring.
2. Creating a data-driven approach that promotes a healthy workforce (manage health risk)
Circulatory, gastrointestinal, and respiratory conditions, largely related to lifestyle choices, continue to drive the top claims by cost and frequency. Meanwhile one-in-five workers has a chronic health condition.
All good risk management plans contain strategies to eliminate intrinsic threats, and healthcare should be no different. Understanding the risk profile of your employees and their dependents — and managing these through data-driven initiatives – can have a significant long-term impact on costs.
Consider (confidential, voluntary, and personalized where appropriate):
- Health promotion – health culture, education, vaccinations, illness, and injury prevention initiatives.
- Supports for people at risk of illness - due to lifestyle, family history, and/or working environment.
- Supports for people with medical conditions - to halt or stem the progression of disease.
- Managing high-cost claimants - optimizing care and, where possible, getting them back into productive work.
Done right, these can deliver empathy and economic benefits simultaneously. Putting your current health profile and management measures under the microscope can help you determine the gaps and inefficiencies in your program.
3. Eliminating inefficiencies through smart financing and placement (drive efficiencies)
You need to ensure that you are eliminating redundant or duplicate benefits by consolidating and harmonizing plans.
At the same time, managing wastage is a critical component of cost containment, as plans can involve significant frictional costs such as administration, profit, and risk charges. Your broker will use various techniques to manage this and should have insight into financial factors influencing rates.
You may wish to consider loyalty-based approaches that provide price concessions in return for longer contract terms or obtaining competitive pricing through volume discount.
Other solutions include:
- Alternative risk transfer approaches, such as self-insurance, profit sharing, centralized underwriting, and use of captives.
- Adjudication and case-management protocols to minimize fraud, ensure expenses are medically necessary, and claims paid are reasonable.
- Service level agreements and audits, which can often identify sources of fraud and opportunities for refunds.
- Simplifying and automating administration.
- Broking regionally and globally.
The COVID-19 pandemic is pushing cost management up the corporate agenda, but achieving this means going beyond the status quo of simply challenging prices at renewal, which will only control costs in the short term.
Employers that are serious about managing expenditures need a multipronged approach over several years that targets the three core levers for cost containment: Designing for value, managing health risks, and driving efficiencies. Only then, can you create cost-effective benefits plans that truly benefit employees.
 Mercer Marsh Benefits. MMB Health Trends: 2020 Insurer Perspective, 2020
 Mercer Marsh Benefits. Health on Demand, 2020