COVID-19: Implications for Manufacturing and Automotive Industries in Asia

Continuing our webcast series on COVID-19’s implications on various industries, on 21 May we looked at navigating the pandemic cycle in the Manufacturing and Automotive industries in Asia.

Joining me on the panel were:

Phil Hobson, Commercial & Consumer Segment Leader, Asia
Phil Ondaatje, Industrial Manufacturing Industry Leader, Asia
Joan Collar, Mercer Marsh Benefits Leader, Asia
Darrick Cheung, Client Engagement and Development Leader, Client Advisory Services, Asia
Adam Russell, Placement Leader, Asia

Overview

There has been a reduction of capacity deployed over the last 6–12 months. Insurers are more selective of risk coverages, placing more pressure on clients to differentiate the quality of their risks. To be in the best position for your next renewal, engage timely with brokers and insurers with a focused but flexible renewal approach.

Manufacturing Shutdown Implications

Prolonged factory closures in manufacturing lines and component suppliers will continue to have major impacts in China, Japan, South Korea, the USA, and India, especially for the availability of stock and parts once markets open up again.

Supply Chain Challenges

The Automotive industry is heavily reliant on just-in-time production models. The Hubei province (Wuhan being the capital) is a key component production location. Many partially completed vehicles will be stored, chalking associated holding costs for original equipment manufacturers (OEMs).

Low Consumer Confidence

Lockdowns make it impossible to visit dealers and have dampened consumer enthusiasm. Early indications of a prolonged drop in sales:

  • India: 88% fall in commercial vehicle sales in April
  • China: 80% drop in passenger vehicles sales in February

The widespread sales declines will have far-reaching impacts for the rest of the year even with positive government stimuli.

Impact of Consumer Behavior

Based on anecdotal indications, some consumers are questioning their continued investment in cars. We may thus see an accelerated shift to mobility services, such as on-demand, subscription, rental, and less direct ownership.

Liquidity

OEMs and dealers are negotiating line of credit extensions to fund business delays in sales. Liquidity will also play a part in finance foreclosures and stock returns with the resultant depreciation.

Facing the Challenges

  • Stay closely connected to your customers via online, mobile, and social channels.
  • Consider a contactless sales process to alleviate anxiety.
  • Enhance your sales model by embracing digital across the entire process along with After Sales engagement.
  • Evaluate discount policies to balance volumes, profitability, market brand, and price image for models and consider bundle programs to protect sticker pricing and future used values.
  • Repeatedly scenario-test your supply chain dependency.
  • Stay as agile as possible.
  • Consider the relevancy of your existing business continuity plan.
  • Employee, stakeholder, and network engagement and transparency are critical.

Cost Savings

From a risk management and insurance perspective, businesses have several tools available to manage costs and improve cash flow. The approaches below were shared by Adam and Darrick.

Speak with your Marsh broker if you believe you have a potential Business Interruption (BI) claim. We can help assess if the policy criteria are met and, subsequently, support the claims preparation to improve expediency.

Review Premiums

With likely changes to revenue figures, a thorough review of your business interruption values may potentially qualify you for a return premium or reduction to future premiums. Any material changes in information provided, manufacturing processes, or business activities, for example, alternative revenue streams from the production of PPE equipment, will have to be updated to the insurers. We recommend discussing this with your broker to determine viability.

Alternatively, we can identify your most economically efficient means to finance your risk through Risk Finance Optimization (RFO), which ultimately gives you information on which risk management programs provide the best financial returns. This process is thorough, so it is best to start this several months ahead of your renewal date.

Alternative Solutions

Alternative Risk Transfer options, such as Parametric Insurance, can be a long-term alternative strategy. The use of a captive may provide access to reinsurance markets and potentially more efficient capital.

Employee Wellbeing and Productivity

Joan talked about how businesses in North Asia, and in particular, China, are returning to work, with plants across China have restarted production.

Insurers have started offering innovative benefits such as telehealth facilities and the home delivery of medicine. While non-pandemic claims will be lower this year, we are expecting a spike next year, but in the long run, these advances should help drive down utilization and costs.

An area of concern is Workers Compensation insurance and solutions, as these policies tend to focus on workplace injuries with the traditional “workplace” being production plants and offices. Given the current trend of reduced hours and working from home, it is best to review your Workers Compensation insurance and solutions with your broker.

Mental Health

Health ministries worldwide have been speaking out on the cost of mental health due to COVID-19, and companies are re-looking at mental health resiliency or Employee Assistance programs.

Key considerations:

  • Readiness for remote working without compromise on productivity and engagement.
  • Communication frequency and adequacy of benefits, particularly outpatient, mental health, preventive cover, and Work Injury Compensation coverage extension.

Recovery Phase

There are three important aspects of this phase:

  • Health and safety: Ensure employees are safe commuting to work and at work. This includes worksite safety, social distancing, equipment disinfection, screening, and testing.
  • Cost management: Understand the cost of returning to work and providing the health and safety aspect.
  • Ensuring productivity and engagement: Provide additional support for mental health programs, wellness initiatives, and additional testing and screening.

Mercer Marsh Benefits has been successful in developing continuation benefits for health and Covid-19 treatment and support benefits, in addition to working with companies to plan their return-to-work strategy. Do contact us if you require such support.

Shifting Risk Profile

Darrick, Phil Ondaatje, and Adam, shared more on the areas Manufacturing and Automotive companies should consider when managing their risk profile changes:

Business Continuity Plan Reviews and Updates

In the short and medium-term, the focus should be on:

  • Staff safety and health: Safe distancing, screening protocols, adequate Personal Protective Equipment, active sanitation equipment, etc.
  • Supply chain: Address issues in distribution channels and overreliance on single suppliers.
  • Planning for recovery or when governments ease restrictions: adopting a phased recovery to a “new normal” of business operations.

Pandemic Risk Vulnerability Assessment and Forecasting Models

In the longer term, these assessments and models enable organizations to evaluate different risk mitigation strategies, manage tail uncertainty under different scenarios (e.g. second wave outbreaks), prioritize strategic projects, and allocate limited resources.

Cyber Threats

The first 100 days of COVID-19 saw a 26–55% increase in cyber scams. With the increased risk of cyber-attacks, companies should financially quantify such new exposure changes and develop appropriate risk management strategies, which can include insurance.

Professional Liability

We expect D&O insurers to increase underwriting scrutiny, so engage with your broker or insurers as early and as openly as possible.

Adam also added insurers expect to see increased number of claims on Employment Practices Liability (EPL) as rapidly evolving HR policies may not have been cross-checked and employees allege discrimination or harassment.

Risk Management and Business Enablement

Darrick, Phil Ondaatje, and Phil Hobson, continued to outline how Marsh can provide immediate support through three primary activities:

  1. Preparedness assessment and advice as the crisis unfolds, for example, ongoing advice that BCPs are “Fit for Purpose”.
  2. Providing additional management capacity, including additional reviews and PMO support to navigate the crisis.
  3. Debriefing (lessons learned) to better prepare for the future.

Our consumer solutions team also develops insurance solutions that can be offered on a B2B2C basis across many industries, for example:

  • Extended warranty programs for OEMs
  • Customer engagement programs for Manufacturing and Automotive companies.
  • Employee benefits top-up programs for employers.

Lastly, Marsh has developed a dedicated risk transfer solution with insurers to consider non-damage Business Interruption cover for Infectious Disease. The policy is triggered either by the World Health Organization (WHO)’s notification of a disease, followed by deaths in country, or by the WHO’s issuance of a Public Health Emergency of International Concern (a PHEIC). If you are interested in learning about this product, or find out more about how Marsh can help, please speak to your Marsh representative.

Click here for the full replay of this webcast.

Please note that Marsh PB Co., Ltd and Marsh McLennan are not engaged by nor involved in any manner with Bonus Ranch and its promotion, and has not placed any insurance for nor insured any of its businesses or operations. Marsh as a licensed insurance broker will not request customers to make payment via non-standard methods, such as the transfer of money to any individual’s bank account.